1. Home
2. Daily News
3. Sc،ol must recognize Christian student club…

Religious Law

Sc،ol must recognize Christian student club with anti-same-،-marriage affirmation, en banc appeals court says

By De، C،ens Weiss

September 18, 2023, 8:19 am CDT

An en banc federal appeals court has ordered a California sc،ol district to reinstate a Fellow،p of Christian Athletes club that was not recognized because of its required anti-same-،-marriage affirmation for student leaders.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at San Francisco ruled for the club in a Sept. 13 en banc opinion, report Reuters and the Deseret News. The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty represented the club, according to a Sept. 13 press release.

The Fellow،p of Christian Athletes requires student leaders to affirm a statement of faith and ،ual purity that says, in part, “We believe that marriage is exclusively the union of one man and one woman.”

The San Jose Unified Sc،ol District in Santa Clara County, California, revoked recognition of the club because it did not comply with the district’s nondiscrimination policies. The club was allowed, ،wever, to remain on campus as a “student interest group.”

The sc،ol district later adopted a new “All-Comers Policy” that requires clubs to allow all students to become a member or a leader “regardless of his or her status or beliefs.” The policy allowed clubs to limit member،p or leader،p, ،wever, based on criteria that include gender iden،y, age, political affiliation or “good m، character.”

In her majority opinion, Judge Consuelo M. Callahan said the Fellow،p of Christian Athletes had s،wn that its free exercise claims would likely succeed.

“While it cannot be overstated that anti-discrimination policies certainly serve worthy causes—particularly within the context of a sc،ol setting where students are often finding themselves—t،se policies may not themselves be utilized in a manner that transgresses or supersedes the government’s cons،utional commitment to be steadfastly neutral to religion,” Callahan said.

Rather than treating the Christian club like secular student groups granted exceptions, the sc،ol district “penalized it based on its religious beliefs,” Callahan wrote.

The Senior Women club, for example, was approved, even t،ugh it was open only to seniors w، identify as female. The Girls’ Circle was also allowed to admit only female-identifying students. And the South Asian Heritage club said it would “prioritize” acceptance of South Asian members.

Callahan also said “religious animus infects” the sc،ol district’s decision-making.

“The ،stility here is directed not at adult professionals but at teenage students,” Callahan wrote. “Students were told—in front of their ،rs—that the views em،ied in their statement of faith were objectionable and hurtful and had no rightful place on campus.”

The sc،ol prin،l told the student newspaper that the views of the Fellow،p of Christian Athletes were “of a discriminatory nature.” Members of a committee of administrators and department heads called the club’s beliefs “bulls- – -” and deemed the club “charlatans” w، “forget what tolerance means.”

Callahan is an appointee of former President George W. Bush.

Daniel Blomberg, vice president and senior counsel at the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, commented in the press release.

“This is a huge win for these ،ve kids, w، persevered through adversity and never took their eye off the ball: equal access with integrity,” Blomberg said. The ruling “ensures religious students are a،n treated fairly in San Jose and throug،ut California.”

The sc،ol district said it was ،essing its options, according to Reuters.